Logan Ibarra is possibly the unluckiest repairman in the world. A late night job should not have landed him in the middle of a mad scientist's squabble, but he soon finds himself surrounded by monsters and further madness with little tools to get out.
Dumbing of Age
David M Willis
Joyce has been homeschooled her entire life until now, when she's suddenly a freshman in college! Things don't go well.
Sleepless Domain
Mary Cagle (Cube Watermelon)
In a world where magical girls and their battles are commonplace, loss has become all too common as well.
Namesake
Isa, Meg
There's ghosts at your heels and fairy tale worlds ahead. What do you do? Jump down the rabbit hole!
Freakshow
Scotty
A festival of broken people, blood flows in the center ring. Come one and come all, to the greatest show in all of Paris.
The Last Diplomat
Cat Farris
Samma and Tark didn't ask to be stuck together, but now they're partners on the adventure of a lifetime.
Cassiopeia Quinn
Gunwild, Psudonym
A cute, pantsless thief is pursued across the stars by a buttoned-up military officer in the spacey, laser-filled future.
The Substitutes
Myisha Haynes
What happens when three roommates accidentally acquire otherworldly and powerful magic weapons destined for someone else?
Stand Still, Stay Silent
Minna Sundberg
A few generations after the end of the world, a small, poorly financed research crew is sent out to rediscover whatever is left of the forbidden old world in the south.
Scape
Lauren
Sula has always preferred to forge her own path, but before she knows it, she is pulled into the middle of a civil war between man and monster!
Quick$ilver
Crypto
The flirtatious, directionless, and ever disastrous Luci searches for excitement in a life of crime, and finds himself caught in a web of messy romance and bad blood.
Blindsprings
Kadi Fedoruk
Tamaura, wrested into a world 300 years in the future, must find a way to save the magic fading from her country.
Kochab
Sarah Webb
A YA F/F fantasy comic about Sonya, a lost skier trying to survive a snowy wilderness and find her way back to her village; and Kyra - a fire spirit trying to fix the home that she let fall apart around her.
Goodbye to Halos
Valerie Halla
Cuddles, gay flirting, weird feelings, and magic-fueled knife fights - it's an adventure across the queer multiverse!
Headless Bliss
Clover
A story about story-telling, and other metaphysical themes such as Nightmares! (Failed) Teamwork! Comedy! And more!
Star Impact
Jack McGee
A young, energetic woman fights her way up in the world of super-powered boxing after discovering the mighty gloves of her missing idol!
Alice and the Nightmare
Misha Krivanek
Alice finally attends University to learn to collect the dreams of humans, meet new friends, and deal with a pesky reflection along the way.
Nigh Heaven & Hell
Scotty
Heather Vodihn is on a simple mission: find her father. However she becomes entangled with two strangers with mysterious powers being stalked by a group with bizarre demands. Heather must learn to trust her new traveling companions, even if she is untrustworthy herself.
Gzhel Guardian
Atla Hrafney, nushanchel
The Railway World is a complex, mysterious network of trains, towns and mechanical monsters. Leo is a Guardian of one of these towns, and although their burn-out and depression has taken hold of them, they have one last job to finish.
The Weave
Rennie Kingsley
A young woman pursued by bad luck is witness to the murder of the Fairy Queen of Summer. Can she get to the bottom of this mystery?
Alexander, The Servant & The Water of Life
Reimena Yee
The 21st century retelling of the life and legends of Alexander the Great.
Trying Human
IntroducingEmy
Two women separated by over half a century are brought together by an alien-filled conspiracy involving murder, mystery and romance!
Guilded Age
T Campbell, John Waltrip, Florence Machina
Welcome to the saga of the working-class adventurer! Enjoy the complete story with new annotations daily!
The Forgotten Order
Christy
A young witch for whom every spell is a misfire finds solace and friendship in her new companion - a cursed doll.
Missing Monday
Elle Skinner
Two girls fall in love through a magic door connecting their worlds. When Monday suddenly goes missing, it's up to Foyle to find her. How she's going to navigate an entirely unfamiliar world is another matter.
The Golden Boar
Magnolia Porter Siddell
A young woman joins a group of summoners who call forth Guardian Beasts to protect their isolated magical island. Unfortunately, her Guardian Beast is nothing like she'd imagined, and he's about to change her life, and everything she thought she knew about herself...
Aquapunk
Lo
In an underwater world of unknown coordinates, inhabited by aliens, ghosts, and robots, a young member of a warrior underclass is framed for a crime and goes on the run. Little does he know he is part of a grand design that only gods and ancestors could choreograph.
Within
Verena Loisel
A young hitman meanders between a reality that seems to happen without him, and his dreams where he is lost in an endless house. When he makes an accidental friend, his world is shaken up and he realizes there are things he can't remember about himself.
Love Not Found
Gina Biggs
Abeille is on a quest to find someone who wants to do it the old-fashioned way in a time when touching has become outdated.
Barbarous
Ananth Hirsh, Yuko Ota
A crummy wizard and an anxious monster have to get over themselves and bring order to an apartment building full of misfits.
Edison Rex
Chris Roberson
The adventures of the world’s greatest villain who, after defeating his superheroic nemesis, decides that he’s the only one left to defend the world.
Monsterkind
Taylor C
Wallace Foster, a young, bright-eyed human social worker, has his entire world view rocked when he's suddenly relocated into a city primarily inhabited by monsters.
Astral Aves
Moon Cabal
A fantasy coming-of-age following the adventures of Astra The Black and friends, as they navigate the mysterious world around them. It's politics, adventure, and the supernatural; oh, and crazy hair.
Beeserker
TJ Cordes
This comic is about a robot powered by bees, but it's also about the kind of people who think filling a robot with bees is a good idea, and why they're wrong.
Ride or Die
Mars Heyward
Ride or Die is an LGBTQ webcomic about two street racers who team up with a demon-possessed muscle car in the search for a missing woman, while being hunted by a deadly religious cult.
Sister Claire
Yamino
In the troubled aftermath of a great war between Witches and her fellow Nuns, novice Sister Claire just wants a purpose.
Saint for Rent
Ru Xu
Saint Halliday runs an inn for Time Travelers. Unfortunately, he seems to attract other supernatural "guests," too.
Little Tiny Things
Clover
What are the little things that move us? The simple joys that warm our bodies and hearts? The micro life of insects that influence our world more than we think? The tiny steps we make everyday to have a happier tomorrow?
Empowered
Adam Warren
A sexy superhero comedy (except when it isn't) about the never-ending struggles of a plucky but very unlucky young superheroine.
Nerf Now!!
Josué Pereira
A cute webcomic about fanservice, video games, and... love. Mostly video games, though.
Darkling Bright
Chris Hazelton
Kieran Bright is a college student home for the summer and roped into an online reunion with his old neighborhood friends in the most recent update of their favorite childhood MMORPG.
At least, he was, and that was the idea...
Join Kieran and his friends as they are pulled into another reality that may or may not be real and are forced to confront their own identities, the nature of simulated universes and reality itself.
Lies Within
Lacey
Lysander's aimless and carefree life is turned upside down when he accidentally discovers that the cute boy next door, Simon, is a literal monster
Sakana
Mad Rupert
Our heroes must navigate a hazardous dating scene, overcome personal anxieties, and wrangle unruly seafood in order to find love, peace of mind, and a paycheck.
How to be a Werewolf
Shawn Lenore
Malaya Walters was bitten by a werewolf as a child. After being raised by her human family, she faces the chance to learn what being a werewolf is really like as an adult.
ARISE, YE SKELETON KING
Brian Clevinger, Escher Cattle, Lee Black
A troupe of wandering "adventurers" down to their last silver "acquire" a map only to find the real treasure was the fiend they dug up along the way.
Cyanide & Happiness
Explosm
Satire, dark humor and surreal humor.
BOOKMARK Click "Tag Page" to bookmark a page. When you return to the site, click "Goto Tag" to continue where you left off.
BUFFER WATCH
Comics are currently drawn and uploaded through:
I think Carla is more attentive to people she thinks are queer, so now that she’s picked up on the subtext that is rapidly becoming text I think she might have dedicated some more mental space to remembering these two.
This is clearly a very peaceful protest. Just young, passionate citizens and students camping out and exercising their rights. I’m sure the local authorities are ran by rational and experienced leadership that have well trained officers instructed to de-escalate and not resort to armed force at the slightest of provocation. Everything will be fine.
Tony’s father seems to be a quite level-headed administrator who does not react inappropriately. However, various law enforcement groups may act on their own without going through him. (local, county, and state police groups)
Oh shit, you’re right. Do they close automatically, or is it the wind or something? Or maybe it’s someone pushing a button from a distance, since there doesn’t seem to be anyone shutting them directly.
Yeah. I can’t defend missing the angle of the fence segment in the third panel, but it’s a little hard to tell what side of the fence those wheels are on.
I was a bit hesitant to point it out at first for i would hope obvious reasons but it reminds me a bit of Disco Elysium. There’s been a shift from the familiar warmth of the college dorms to the sobering cold reality of the snow painted canvas of Dunn Meadow immediately took me back to Revachol. It’s taking me a lot not to snap into a long winded faux DE monologue that would probably be way lamer than cool.
Probably gonna have to nuke the campus, just to be sure. It looks like someone’s got a drink kettle or something, over by that tent. It’s probably full of bombs and emails, better to just wipe it off the map.
It seemed like a thing Joss urgently needed to know, and I don’t think Joyce is fully cognizant of the danger. Dorothy probably is, but she’s also not the one leading here.
Among other reasons: in case the dad in question responds by coming there in person. (Or if anyone else sees them. Were I in Jocelyne’s position, I’d be worried about some kiwifarms types crawling out of the woodwork. Possibly in some kind of laughable supervillain cosplay.)
Why would he drive four hours to show up in person because he saw a photo of her at a protest? And what would happen if he did? She lives independently, so he can’t threaten to kick her out. She’s not dressed femme, so her being trans probably isn’t going to come up. I may be missing something, but it seems to me that Joyce panicked and isn’t thinking things through.
I agree with the vibe that Joyce is overreacting out of panic. I sorta wonder if whatever commotion is coming wouldn’t be coming if she’d thought about it for a few more seconds before going in all guns blazin’.
Some phones still have GPS running even in airplane mode, or are capable of storing location data for later retrieval, and I just generally don’t trust companies to be honest about what data they do and do not collect and/or pass on to the authorities.
GPT-based tracking does still happen in airplane mode. It doesn’t transmit out at that time, but the data remains on the phone. When next the phone is connection-enabled, any on-phone apps that share location data (metadata, etc) will immediately begin transmitting that data. If the phone is seized, law enforcement, et al, can find the location tracking data on it.
like, strictly speaking, whether or not you have your phone on you, whatever they want to know they have other ways of knowing. while it’s important to care about privacy in general, it’s also important to be realistic
also I’m just gonna say it because it seems it really needs to be said —
the idea the governments are all-seeing, all-knowing, etc, is Nazi propaganda
I’m a little curious, since it’s being discussed. If my location data is there, don’t the pigs have to suspect me of being there in the first place for that to matter? And then we need to consider how many people walk past a protest while it’s happening. They probably have their phones, meaning they would flag as being there, too. Is 7-11 Andy getting arrested because he walked by on his way to get a slushy? Don’t they have to actually get the data from your phone first? I assume there’s not just a pig sitting at a magic computer that hoovers up all the GPS data of every phone near a target location and automatically generated arrest warrants.
There are actually devices called Stingrays that have existed for over 20 years, that capture the identifying details of every phone in an area. Then, whichever three letter agency who wants to do it can just ask the cell carriers who an IMEI belongs to.
And, with triangulation, they don’t need the GPS data, they just need three cell sites and the relative signal strengths.
Don’t those two statements contradict?
“the idea the governments are all-seeing, all-knowing, etc, is Nazi propaganda”
and
“whatever they want to know they have other ways of knowing”
it’s exactly my point that it’s easy to think that in an atmosphere of paranoia that the Oppressor seeks to instill
in times like this, it is important to know that most of the power of authoritarianism is freely given to it by ordinary people
By any means, they seek to instill fear and depend on citizens to give into it, into the will to Obey In Advance, because that’s literally doing over half the work for them
FWIW I have done experiments simply wrapping a phone in aluminum foil and trying to call it. The foil effectively blocks incoming signals. and I presume, outgoing.
Of course, shut the phone off or it will exhaust the battery trying to connect.
No no, you have a point even there; we haven’t had any information about the protests being at all violent iirc – if I’m wrong, please send me the relevant strips – so it wouldn’t make sense that they’d be worried about any kind of danger going into this area. Like, with all the info we have on this, it seems about as dangerous as going into one of those Occupy Wallstreet protest areas where they had tents and stuff set up in open areas for their protest – unless this is more of a CHAZ/CHOP/whatever kind of protest, I don’t see how they’d think of this as a “entering the belly of the beast” kind of situation.
yall realize that peaceful protests get escalated by police all the time in the states, right? If you believe otherwise, that’s the propaganda you’re believing. Police infiltrate protests then throw rocks and incite stuff to violence ALL. THE. TIME. They have every right to be worried, with the state of things right now
Yeah yeah, real life protest = dangerous, for fuck’s sake. Everyone fucking knows that. It doesn’t have to paint my expectation of Joyce and Dorothy’s well-being while they’re at this one, and it’s really goddamn condescending for so many comments to basically be repetitions of “Um, actually, real protests are dangerous actually” as if anyone not in a frothing panic is just uninformed.
The reason you (and I) can be *so* certain that Joyce and Dorothy are going to be just fine is at least in part due to their plot armor. If these were two random real people at a random real protest, the chances are *good* that they would also be fine, but given the very real and non-negligible chances of violence erupting even at protests that begin peacefully, I don’t think you’d be able to have the same degree of certainty you seem to be showing here.
I don’t see how Bulmerian students are threatened by them, either. They’re here to deliver a message that probably could’ve waited, not to actively participate in the protest.
I mean, Willis would have to be a much worse writer than he is to hit the “protests are dangerous” reminder half a dozen times and then not fire checkov’s gun, especially in a story that has hit these kinds of stakes before. Like, readers are nervous because the narrative has built the tension up, both with in-story reminders and by connection to events happening irl that inspired this storyline.
No one died in To Those Who’d Ground Me, but it was hardly without consequence, right? Both for the characters and their arcs, and for the broader plot. Would you *prefer* the story go with “Joyce and Dorothy get pushed over, and that’s all that happens”? Maybe that’s more realistic, but would it be narratively satisfying to you? Or do you want to see things escalate and become tense and exciting and action-filled, in concert to the stakes being built?
I reject your short-sighted dichotomy. What I’d personally like to see most is Joyce and Dorothy sticking around the protest after they deliver their piddly coulda-waited message to Jocelyne, realizing nobody’s around to hold them accountable or probably even recognize them, and start making out behind a tent. With this comic, I don’t often care about exciting violent action like fight scenes or kidnappings or cops existing, so dangling that in front of me like a carrot won’t get a response you probably like. I wanna see these dipshit queers do messy things with their friends, and if they get tear gassed it’s none of my business.
Like, we’ve already had two violent and perilous season finales, so do we really need a third? The “Rule” of Threes is old hat. When’s the last time you saw a Big Dramatic Arc that had a little bit of danger and way more ill-advised makeouts than usual? Physical harm is an easy way to raise the stakes, but it can’t be the only way or it gets repetitive. Until and unless Joyce and Dorothy lock lips, I’m not convinced anything is at stake.
I hope they’re all right at this event, though the fence behind put up behind them worries me. And my knowledge of how campus protesters were treated by the authorities last year around the time these strips were written has me worried too.
Lots of colleges and universities called the cops to arrest student protesters last year, and cops don’t exactly have the best record with how they treat protesters. Especially when they’re people protesting against evil things that the US government is doing, like aiding a genocide.
How often do these two actually come to any major harm? Somebody always intervenes before it gets too severe. Hell, the longest-lasting physical damage Joyce has taken was basically self-inflicted, when she punched Becky’s dad hard enough to put her hand in a brace for a little while. It would be silly of me to expect these two are gonna get genuinely hurt, after reading this comic so many times and seeing them always come out basically fine.
Eh, I’d be surprised if either sustained more than superficial injury, but if one or both of them ended up getting arrested I wouldn’t be surprised.
We’re coming up on the point in the first “season” where Becky got kidnapped, I expect things at this protest to escalate beyond the norm for this comic.
And while they’re in the overnight cell with about 200 other people, they both notice the other is lookin’ pretty fine behind bars, and since there’s not much else to do in a jail cell, they start making out. I like this idea you had that’s yours.
An arrest is definitely possible, especially since they arrived at a critical moment, judging by the fences going up. Getting a bit roughed up in the process is also possible. Tear gas. Serious injury or death is very unlikely – even without plot armor. That isn’t to excuse any violence from cops (or the policy to clear the encampment), but the danger is routinely exaggerated – partly just because violence is the only part that makes the news.
It’s possible the fence is being put up to trap all the protesters for arrest, but it’s more likely they want to control access – keep new protesters from arriving or people from wandering in and out. Let anyone who wants to leave and then arrest those who stay.
Dumbing of Age: a story ripped from last year’s headlines!
…and unfortunately this year’s and quite possibly next year’s as well. Unless things get even worse between now and then, which seems likely…
Cops here are chickenshit cowards who only care about who they’re gonna murder next, and if we see one we have to assume it’s no exception. I can see the wisdom of not letting them track you in a contentious crowd, even if I personally wouldn’t follow the advice.
My heart started racing. I’m devouring this strip pixel by pixel. The angles! The colors! Joyce’s eyes being the most saturated thing! God, they were walking in hand in hand, and a fence closed right after they came in for reasons unknown.
The subversion of the title (and the “it was bound to happen eventually”, of sapphic risky decisions) is the cherry on top of a _really_ delicious sundae.
Reasons unknown, but highly guessable, given the environment. I’m willing to bet the fence is there to keep the protesters caged in and agitate them so they’re more likely to act up, like in real life.
NO PR(oresting?)
BY CI(ty?)
COUN(cil?)
ORD(inance?)
I meant it more like, we don’t know how it’s gonna develop (including when shit’s gonna hit the fan.) I’m seated, though ^^ It’s gonna be a tricky storyline to navigate, what with the Very Real Life parallels (that keep and keep going, gdi) — but I wholly trust Willis as a storyteller.
Things have been bad for quite a while, yes. Honestly, I don’t think it’s ever stopped getting worse since at least 9/11, and probably before that. People like to pretend 2016 was some sort of anomaly that marked the start of the Current Shit, but it was consistently horrid for a long time beforehand.
I just want to point out the fact that Joyce has, at this point, been drugged and nearly raped, smashed the girl’s face open with glass, rode with Sal to rescue her best friend from being kidnapped by an armed gunman, was kidnapped, hogtied in a basement, where it was apparent that endgame was their death, was the one chosen by her group of abductees as the one most rage-filled and therefore the most dangerous, then got kidnapped again and helped toss a kid to be caught in midair by a motorcycle.
But no, they’re going to a peaceful protest on campus and THIS is what is truly terrifying.
I’m not sure if they’re so PTSD’d that something which is truly mildly subversive is in actuality akin to walking in a warzone, or if in this universe, college protests are extremely unusual and often put down with lethal force and extreme prejudice.
Its admittedly been a while since I was in college, but there’d be protests half the weekend about one thing or another.
I would encourage you to look into the way anti-police/anti-war/anti-genocide protests in the States have been responded to by police in recent years in the universe we live in.
I’m not denying at all that there’s a small percentage of peaceful protests that do result in a some level of police retaliation and arrests, or of violence in general.
What I stand by – and I 100% do – is that it is safer to enter a peaceful demonstration, with a buddy, long enough to find your sister, deliver a message, and leave – something that should take ten to fifteen minutes tops – than for two short underage college girls to go alone to a bar, get smashed drunk, and stagger through the streets of their town completely inebriated until they get back on campus. And they willingly chose to do the former without much thought to the consequences.
I’m not sure about the timeline depending on the size and vibe of the protest, but I do agree with your overall idea. What’s interesting is that they’ve been conditioned to think of the protest option as scary and the bar option as normal– which I think is the case for a lot of people their age. Many people do things that can be very scary or risky all the time, but they don’t think of them that way because the things are “normal.”
Both things they should be able to do without real danger, but unfortunately it’s a risk to some degree in each.
From an outside perspective, it makes sense to think that the chances of them encountering danger during this task are low, even if they don’t feel that way. Then you take another step in perspective to consider that this is a comic and we expect some sort of even to happen, and I can see where readers might be worried about something happening to them.
They’re obviously arriving at a dramatic moment, considering the fence being put up, but yeah, there’s definitely conditioning to think of protesting as scary (and we see it not just with them, but with a lot of commenters).
I think everything I would say is the summary that one of the Palestinian protestors only just now got released and the President still wants him in jail.
The level of danger also varies by protest and the likelihood of something happening while there also varies with how long someone is there. Like, definitely getting some clues that Dorothy and Joyce just have the worst timing, but presumably there have been plenty of other fifteen minute windows where they would have been fine.
It definitely does. Most protest rally kind of things are almost completely safe – like the No Kings last weekend. Encampments like this are higher risk, since they’re likely eventually going to be cleared out. Even then, there’s usually the opportunity to leave before the cops decide to go in with force.
If you’re going to night protests where there’s already been violence on previous days? Be ready for street fighting.
For real, though. If someone tries to genuinely hurt Joyce or Dorothy, Joyce is just gonna go all Kaio-ken on their ass and probably Amazi-Girl will show up to punch several identical white guys. It’ll be a fun fight scene, but I’ll change my name to Punished Taffy for a month if Joyce or Dorothy gets any injury more severe than a mild black eye.
Police in the US often don’t treat protesters very well, especially when those protesters are protesting against genocide, war, or previous bad actions of the police.
This is all true, but at the same time, the danger is often wildly overstated. The vast majority of protesters walk away completely unharmed. Shit does happen. The police do get violent and there’s no excuse for that, but still overwhelmingly it’s still safe to protest. The media focuses on the violence of course, so that sets the impression.
Go protest. You’re not actually taking your life in your hands.
I would like to point out that I, personally, am a person within the United States who has been a part of more than one protest, and yet somehow I am both alive, without an arrest record, and in possession of most of my teeth.
For everyone saying, “OK, but you’re CLEARLY not familiar with how protests go in Amurica, they have guns and evil police,” congrats, you’re engaging in stereotype.
Protests can go bad. No one’s denying that. Police violence does happen. Protestor violence happens too, though more rarely. People get arrested unjustly. These things happen. They shouldn’t. It’s indefensible.
But it’s also not the common experience. Vast majority of protestors don’t go through any of that.
Why are we so dedicated to pushing the idea that protesting is incredibly dangerous? Who does that serve?
I think thejeff is pointing to the strip at this point. Narratives about the dangers of protesting, particularly those centered on main characters, create the impression that such dangers are ‘typical’ of protests in general. This, in turn, creates reluctance to actually engage in protests, thereby diminishing their effectiveness.
Yeah, I don’t really get the scaremongering. Even simple statements like “I don’t think they’re in much danger” is just being invariably met with “But real protests can be dangerous”, like that’s supposed to fix our flawed naivete and make us scared for Joyce and Dorothy.
I’m arguing that it’s unreasonable to, when showing up to a protest for a planned fifteen minute jaunt, be loudly terrified that you might be killed, because the chances of that happening are incredibly miniscule.
25 people were killed in the US in 2020 while protesting. There were over 10,600 protests across the US that year. Statistics show that over 95% were completely peaceful, and that there was no property damage or physical injury, either on police or protestor side, for 98% of them.
Protest sizes ranged from a few hundred to a few thousand, so let’s be generous here and say that there was, on average, 300 attendees for each protest. That would mean that your chance of being killed attending a protest in 2020 would be 1 in 127,200.
In comparison, statistics by the National Safety Council also show that your chance of being in a car accident is roughly 1 in 366 for every 1,000 miles you drive. If you crunch the numbers – and I did – that means that if you drove five miles to get to the protest, you were in more danger driving to the protest than participating in it.
But no, I’m the one using anecdotes to try to push a narrative, rather than demonstrate that Joyce and Dorothy are perhaps being a tad melodramatic when they exclaim loudly that they sure hope they’ll keep being alive.
I’m inclined to take the word of someone who’s actually been at a protest and didn’t die, over the incessant pants-wetting of people who are too afraid to even consider the odds of returning alive might be higher than 0%.
And you know what that is not an stereotype that is an accurate statement about america. It got a massive gun and police violence problem, it’s not up for debate.
I think you don’t know what the word ‘stereotype’ means.
As you stand here making a loud, unshakable statement about a different group of people, which you have gathered from a lot of what has been said about those people, and refuse to listen to reasoned arguments that claim that yes, while SOME are like this, you cannot assume that ALL are like this, or even MOST are like this. You instead say, no, I am not debating or discussing this, those people have a massive problem, it is exactly what I say it is.
Okay, and did all of them involve people coming from outside the school, like Joss has, news coverage, which is how Hank knows about this, and someone cordoning off the area, like we’re seeing in this strip? Or does that suggest something bigger and potentially more likely to involve polive violence than protests that happen “half the weekend about one thing or another”?
So, I just did a little digging, and looked up what was happening with protests at UIB specifically during the time these strips would’ve been written. A pro-protest site I found did not talk about actual serious injuries or deaths; it did, however, talk about temporary arrests (charges were ultimately not filed, due to the prosecutors’ concerns that the arrests themselves were unconstitutional) and the University coming up with very targeted policies about ‘temporary structures’ meant to disperse the protestors, and about students being charged with violations of UIB policy–which could lead to suspension from campus.
Interestingly, the non-lethal consequences I mention above are actually, by virtue of being non-lethal, absolutely something that could happen to one or both of the girls, with long-lasting ramifications (especially for Dotty–an arrest for being a protestor would absolutely be the final nail in the coffin to her political ambitions).
They definitely did. I wonder how long they managed to separate their hands while they were getting dressed. I imagine seconds at most, just long enough to slip a sleeve past.
The argument about not having your phone and disguising your identity is good to avoid the police arresting you or harrassing you. Other people think that you actually have to be willing to be arrested to make the protests work. Sadly, very few people want to be a martyr nor should anyone have to be.
It’s not like we have evidence that the local police are corrupt and tied to the mob. Willing to kill to protect themselves from discovery. They wouldn’t hurt someone in a public place like a park or a hospital. And get totally away with it.
Honestly I’m really proud of both of them. Something like this would have been too politically dangerous for Dorothy, once. And unthinkable for Joyce, once.
…. I mean, she has to be, right? It’s not like the power structures at hand would treat the protest and counter-protest with anything other than total, even-handed equality, right? Right?
Happy Nonbinary People's Day, you gemstones. A year or two back we introduced FLASH GORDON's first enby, the outlaw lawman Bones Malock. Having known and loved a lot of nonbinary people, I knew the truest way to represent you was as a unsettling desert pirate with a lightning sword
Happy International Non-Binary People's Day to all those who work, create, parent, protest, love and live without ever fitting into someone else's category.
Okay, everyone's jumping to conclusions, but Joyce was hit with a mysterious pink gas in Thursday's strip.
Now, in recent years, the police are known to increasingly use military grade weapons.
Which reminded me of this bit of proposed technology from the 1990s:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gay_bomb
hey, kid, what do you want to play with from the cool superhero movie? is it a nude, melting senator who feels like a stretch armstrong doll that has been left out in the son and maybe mildly chewed by a neighborhood dog? WELL, SON, YOU'RE IN LUCK!
Joyce is absolutely totally straight and just wants to hang out with her best friend, who happens to be another lady. This is normal behavior and a normal biblical quote to use that has no other context.
GAL PALS
OK, I said I was going to a thread of receipts together on the guy who runs Kapow, in odder to explain why I personally would recommend not giving him your business at TFN.
Starting with the original post, revealing the guy loves sharing right wing fascist stuff on LinkedIn.
Alex Maw@xjmaw.bsky.social ⋅ 6m
Since you might think it's weird you got a like on this over a year after the fact, the director of Kapow just shared this on LinkedIn; i.imgur.com/hqQYWgO.png
You go girls!!! I’m nervous for them
I wonder how much harder of a time Carla would have tellin them apart now.
Don’t be ridiculous; Joyce is the one with the jugs!
I think Carla is more attentive to people she thinks are queer, so now that she’s picked up on the subtext that is rapidly becoming text I think she might have dedicated some more mental space to remembering these two.
Oooooh they’ve been kettled
Hahaeeheheohdear…
fenced in, not kettled. kettling’s down with bodies, not barriers
I thought it was a universal term.
The more you know
It can be both. They’ll bring fences with them sometimes, or have a fence area set up and use bodies for the rest.
Oh good. They can make a nice cup of tea. /s
I, too, hope to continue feeling this exact portion alive, Joyce.
Any more alive and I’d probably be insufferable.
Oh! The way they put their arms around eachother there at the end.
My sapphic heart is aflutter!
Didn’t figured out how they are holding hands when entering the camp.
Are they walking all the way from campus like this?
Yeah, they’re holding hands and walking to the protest, then they get there and put their arms around each other. What needs figuring out about that?
It somewhat mirrors the pose of the original line. https://www.dumbingofage.com/2018/comic/book-9-comic/01-flyin-to-the-red/subterfuge/
Ominous fence closing
I didn’t even catch that until you mentioned it. Thanks. I think?
It’ll be fine. I’m sure nothing will come of this powderkeg in a cage
This is clearly a very peaceful protest. Just young, passionate citizens and students camping out and exercising their rights. I’m sure the local authorities are ran by rational and experienced leadership that have well trained officers instructed to de-escalate and not resort to armed force at the slightest of provocation. Everything will be fine.
We’ve definitely learned better since Kent State.
Tony’s father seems to be a quite level-headed administrator who does not react inappropriately. However, various law enforcement groups may act on their own without going through him. (local, county, and state police groups)
Or vigilantes. Some teenager from the next state over maybe.
Oh shit, you’re right. Do they close automatically, or is it the wind or something? Or maybe it’s someone pushing a button from a distance, since there doesn’t seem to be anyone shutting them directly.
There’s the silhouette of a person closing the gate.
It looks to me less like someone closing a gate and more like someone putting up a fence, though I could be wrong
A really shitty fence, at that. No supports on the corners, it’s just kinda stood there. Looks easy to knock over.
Yeah. I can’t defend missing the angle of the fence segment in the third panel, but it’s a little hard to tell what side of the fence those wheels are on.
there’s a figure in panel 4 moving the fence. The red sign looks like it’s an ex post facto application of a county ordinance.
Hey uh, someone more familiar with the geography of the IU campus, is there normally a big fence in this park?
Is there normally a big fence being haphazardly placed by a rando with a wagonload of fence segments? No, probably not.
Oh, that is a wagon. My first assumption was wheeled gate, which it clearly isn’t on second look.
It might be a trailer attached to a small vehicle, too. Maybe a quad bike or buggy.
There was for a while, following the anti-genocide protests. It was removed in December, after 136 days.
Hopefully there’s another way out of the area.
Soon as they show up, suddenly a chainlink fence?? :O
To the tune of “Suddenly Seymour” ♪ ♪Suddenly chain link is closing behind you♪ ♪
Again, hoping for a protest sign like ‘Can you imagine if our leader was the villain in every movie, at least shit’s not that bad.’
Fiction should be aspirational.
Yes, all the best protest signs are both incoherent and conciliatory.
For some reason panel 4 make me think of a point and click adventure game. That actually woild be pretty neat.
I was a bit hesitant to point it out at first for i would hope obvious reasons but it reminds me a bit of Disco Elysium. There’s been a shift from the familiar warmth of the college dorms to the sobering cold reality of the snow painted canvas of Dunn Meadow immediately took me back to Revachol. It’s taking me a lot not to snap into a long winded faux DE monologue that would probably be way lamer than cool.
Omg i love disco Elysium! Making a dumbing of age AU would be pretty cool.
Jennifer/Billy in the role of Harry Du Bois?
I love that game.
Examine Tent:
This ain't no Yuru Camp we walkin' into.
Obvious exits are NORTH, SOUTH, and DENNIS.
What wouldst thou deau?
> GET FLASK
Ye can’t get ye flask!
AH! THE FONT IS DIFFERENT!
It is not!
It’s the increased resolution. The font renders a bit differently.
oh SNAP WE’RE HD!!!
DUN DUN DUNNNN (Meadow)
+1 point to you
Time for a new font then!
I thought that might be it!
it’s the same hamburger, but crispier
THE FONT IS UNDIFFERENT NOW
The resolution is now the normal resomoultion, too.
They seem dangerous. Better call the marines to stop them.
Probably gonna have to nuke the campus, just to be sure. It looks like someone’s got a drink kettle or something, over by that tent. It’s probably full of bombs and emails, better to just wipe it off the map.
last panel resume my fears when I went to a protest first time
Oh no, that sudden appearance of fencing is worrying.
So there wasn’t…like, a REAL reason to go contact Jocelyne, in person, immediately. Right?
Sure her dad recognized her, but I feel like if Joyce & Dorothy weren’t prepared for this, it was a pretty reckless thing to do.
Yeah yeah I know, not called smarting of age blah blah blah
It seemed like a thing Joss urgently needed to know, and I don’t think Joyce is fully cognizant of the danger. Dorothy probably is, but she’s also not the one leading here.
What was the thing she needed to know urgently? I’m not following.
Her dad saw a photo of her.
Protest op-sec says no phones to avoid tracking. Going in person was the only way to guarantee contact within the next few hours.
Yes I’m aware of that, but why? What purpose does it serve to tell Jocelyne her dad might’ve seen her on the news?
I mean to tell her RIGHT NOW, as opposed to in five hours or whenever she meets up with them/checks her phone again.
At the very least, it feels like it would be the last thing on her mind in the midst of a protest.
It moves the plot along.
Among other reasons: in case the dad in question responds by coming there in person. (Or if anyone else sees them. Were I in Jocelyne’s position, I’d be worried about some kiwifarms types crawling out of the woodwork. Possibly in some kind of laughable supervillain cosplay.)
Why would he drive four hours to show up in person because he saw a photo of her at a protest? And what would happen if he did? She lives independently, so he can’t threaten to kick her out. She’s not dressed femme, so her being trans probably isn’t going to come up. I may be missing something, but it seems to me that Joyce panicked and isn’t thinking things through.
I agree with the vibe that Joyce is overreacting out of panic. I sorta wonder if whatever commotion is coming wouldn’t be coming if she’d thought about it for a few more seconds before going in all guns blazin’.
How out of character for Joyce to panic and not think things through. And in the comic Smarting of Age too.
like I heard you could just put your phone in air-plane mode to made sure the tracking shit don’t happen, is this true? :0
Some phones still have GPS running even in airplane mode, or are capable of storing location data for later retrieval, and I just generally don’t trust companies to be honest about what data they do and do not collect and/or pass on to the authorities.
GPT-based tracking does still happen in airplane mode. It doesn’t transmit out at that time, but the data remains on the phone. When next the phone is connection-enabled, any on-phone apps that share location data (metadata, etc) will immediately begin transmitting that data. If the phone is seized, law enforcement, et al, can find the location tracking data on it.
like, strictly speaking, whether or not you have your phone on you, whatever they want to know they have other ways of knowing. while it’s important to care about privacy in general, it’s also important to be realistic
also I’m just gonna say it because it seems it really needs to be said —
the idea the governments are all-seeing, all-knowing, etc, is Nazi propaganda
I’m a little curious, since it’s being discussed. If my location data is there, don’t the pigs have to suspect me of being there in the first place for that to matter? And then we need to consider how many people walk past a protest while it’s happening. They probably have their phones, meaning they would flag as being there, too. Is 7-11 Andy getting arrested because he walked by on his way to get a slushy? Don’t they have to actually get the data from your phone first? I assume there’s not just a pig sitting at a magic computer that hoovers up all the GPS data of every phone near a target location and automatically generated arrest warrants.
There are actually devices called Stingrays that have existed for over 20 years, that capture the identifying details of every phone in an area. Then, whichever three letter agency who wants to do it can just ask the cell carriers who an IMEI belongs to.
And, with triangulation, they don’t need the GPS data, they just need three cell sites and the relative signal strengths.
Sure, they can. But are they just going out and rounding up everyone who was near a protest?
That’s pretty scary, tbh. I wonder how often it actually gets used, compared to how many protests occur.
Don’t those two statements contradict?
“the idea the governments are all-seeing, all-knowing, etc, is Nazi propaganda”
and
“whatever they want to know they have other ways of knowing”
it’s exactly my point that it’s easy to think that in an atmosphere of paranoia that the Oppressor seeks to instill
in times like this, it is important to know that most of the power of authoritarianism is freely given to it by ordinary people
By any means, they seek to instill fear and depend on citizens to give into it, into the will to Obey In Advance, because that’s literally doing over half the work for them
FWIW I have done experiments simply wrapping a phone in aluminum foil and trying to call it. The foil effectively blocks incoming signals. and I presume, outgoing.
Of course, shut the phone off or it will exhaust the battery trying to connect.
Meanwhile there are protests out there asking you to RSVP.
The resolution bump!!!! Incredible!!!!!!
Good eye. 1000×333 yesterday, 4800×1600 today.
Your mom is a resolution bump
No, you were the resolution bump inside your Mom.
(for a few months, anyway)
Sure hope Sal didn’t leave her phone in a jacket pocket!
“Sally Walkerton, we have evidence you were at the unauthorized and illegal protest.”
“Ah mean, that sounds like me. . .”
The art and storytelling in this strip is flat out fucking incredible.
Toxic Yuri Status: RAINBOW QUARTZ
“What can I do for you? What can I do that no one else can do”
Wait.
Is that dark jacket the same one that has RUTTEN in large letters on the sleeve?
Hm, looking at the stitching pattern, I suspect not:
https://www.dumbingofage.com/hey/
Yeesh. They’re not gonna die, and the structures of power aren’t gonna be threatened by them telling Jocelyne that Hank saw a photo of her.
It is a protest in the united states, the possibility of fatalities is never zero.
That’s irrelevant. These two aren’t gonna die.
Yeah we know that, the characters don’t know that though.
Oh, well.
No no, you have a point even there; we haven’t had any information about the protests being at all violent iirc – if I’m wrong, please send me the relevant strips – so it wouldn’t make sense that they’d be worried about any kind of danger going into this area. Like, with all the info we have on this, it seems about as dangerous as going into one of those Occupy Wallstreet protest areas where they had tents and stuff set up in open areas for their protest – unless this is more of a CHAZ/CHOP/whatever kind of protest, I don’t see how they’d think of this as a “entering the belly of the beast” kind of situation.
I’m gonna chalk it up to their emotions being heightened from all the horny energy they just had interrupted.
Protestors usually aren’t the ones who initiate violence.
yall realize that peaceful protests get escalated by police all the time in the states, right? If you believe otherwise, that’s the propaganda you’re believing. Police infiltrate protests then throw rocks and incite stuff to violence ALL. THE. TIME. They have every right to be worried, with the state of things right now
Yeah yeah, real life protest = dangerous, for fuck’s sake. Everyone fucking knows that. It doesn’t have to paint my expectation of Joyce and Dorothy’s well-being while they’re at this one, and it’s really goddamn condescending for so many comments to basically be repetitions of “Um, actually, real protests are dangerous actually” as if anyone not in a frothing panic is just uninformed.
The protestors being violent isn’t the dnager here.
Would this scene be improved if both characters were aware of and confident in their plot armour to keep them safe from harm?
Let’s not bother with bad-faith questions like this.
It’s just a rhetorical question
It’s what you said, so if it’s bad faith…
It’s not what I said, actually, if you read the words that are there without inventing new ones.
The reason you (and I) can be *so* certain that Joyce and Dorothy are going to be just fine is at least in part due to their plot armor. If these were two random real people at a random real protest, the chances are *good* that they would also be fine, but given the very real and non-negligible chances of violence erupting even at protests that begin peacefully, I don’t think you’d be able to have the same degree of certainty you seem to be showing here.
But they’re not real people at a real protest, so that doesn’t need to be a factor in my assessment of the comic.
Yeah, they’re mainly gonna be threatening to students of Bulmerian descent at the school. The power structures are doing fine either way.
I don’t see how Bulmerian students are threatened by them, either. They’re here to deliver a message that probably could’ve waited, not to actively participate in the protest.
I mean, Willis would have to be a much worse writer than he is to hit the “protests are dangerous” reminder half a dozen times and then not fire checkov’s gun, especially in a story that has hit these kinds of stakes before. Like, readers are nervous because the narrative has built the tension up, both with in-story reminders and by connection to events happening irl that inspired this storyline.
No one died in To Those Who’d Ground Me, but it was hardly without consequence, right? Both for the characters and their arcs, and for the broader plot. Would you *prefer* the story go with “Joyce and Dorothy get pushed over, and that’s all that happens”? Maybe that’s more realistic, but would it be narratively satisfying to you? Or do you want to see things escalate and become tense and exciting and action-filled, in concert to the stakes being built?
I reject your short-sighted dichotomy. What I’d personally like to see most is Joyce and Dorothy sticking around the protest after they deliver their piddly coulda-waited message to Jocelyne, realizing nobody’s around to hold them accountable or probably even recognize them, and start making out behind a tent. With this comic, I don’t often care about exciting violent action like fight scenes or kidnappings or cops existing, so dangling that in front of me like a carrot won’t get a response you probably like. I wanna see these dipshit queers do messy things with their friends, and if they get tear gassed it’s none of my business.
You’re so right bestie, I can’t believe I’ve let my yuri senses be clouded by the promise of violent action. More makeouts, Willis!
Like, we’ve already had two violent and perilous season finales, so do we really need a third? The “Rule” of Threes is old hat. When’s the last time you saw a Big Dramatic Arc that had a little bit of danger and way more ill-advised makeouts than usual? Physical harm is an easy way to raise the stakes, but it can’t be the only way or it gets repetitive. Until and unless Joyce and Dorothy lock lips, I’m not convinced anything is at stake.
We should all be thankful to Taffy today for reminding us where our narrative priorities lie.
I hope they’re all right at this event, though the fence behind put up behind them worries me. And my knowledge of how campus protesters were treated by the authorities last year around the time these strips were written has me worried too.
Worst I anticipate is one of them getting knocked over by someone who’s running past them, maybe a scare from some commotion.
Lots of colleges and universities called the cops to arrest student protesters last year, and cops don’t exactly have the best record with how they treat protesters. Especially when they’re people protesting against evil things that the US government is doing, like aiding a genocide.
Also while the protesters might not get violent, the counter-protesters might.
Yes, I’m aware. I just don’t see Joyce and Dorothy getting more than a little bumped around during a scuffle.
Why?
How often do these two actually come to any major harm? Somebody always intervenes before it gets too severe. Hell, the longest-lasting physical damage Joyce has taken was basically self-inflicted, when she punched Becky’s dad hard enough to put her hand in a brace for a little while. It would be silly of me to expect these two are gonna get genuinely hurt, after reading this comic so many times and seeing them always come out basically fine.
Eh, I’d be surprised if either sustained more than superficial injury, but if one or both of them ended up getting arrested I wouldn’t be surprised.
We’re coming up on the point in the first “season” where Becky got kidnapped, I expect things at this protest to escalate beyond the norm for this comic.
And while they’re in the overnight cell with about 200 other people, they both notice the other is lookin’ pretty fine behind bars, and since there’s not much else to do in a jail cell, they start making out. I like this idea you had that’s yours.
I wouldn’t be surprised.
An arrest is definitely possible, especially since they arrived at a critical moment, judging by the fences going up. Getting a bit roughed up in the process is also possible. Tear gas. Serious injury or death is very unlikely – even without plot armor. That isn’t to excuse any violence from cops (or the policy to clear the encampment), but the danger is routinely exaggerated – partly just because violence is the only part that makes the news.
It’s possible the fence is being put up to trap all the protesters for arrest, but it’s more likely they want to control access – keep new protesters from arriving or people from wandering in and out. Let anyone who wants to leave and then arrest those who stay.
Dumbing of Age: a story ripped from last year’s headlines!
…and unfortunately this year’s and quite possibly next year’s as well. Unless things get even worse between now and then, which seems likely…
it’s pretty terrifying that “don’t bring a phone with you to not be trackable” is something that must be done in the US for peaceful protests.
Cops here are chickenshit cowards who only care about who they’re gonna murder next, and if we see one we have to assume it’s no exception. I can see the wisdom of not letting them track you in a contentious crowd, even if I personally wouldn’t follow the advice.
Even the most peaceful demonstration can be condemned as a riot if someone in charge yell it loud enough.
I’m still shocked that so many people agree to carry a tracker on their person at all times. But clearly I’m not in the majority.
Jocelyne stepped away for a bathroom break so she’s not here and then the riot police start their riot and Joyce winds up getting arrested
My heart started racing. I’m devouring this strip pixel by pixel. The angles! The colors! Joyce’s eyes being the most saturated thing! God, they were walking in hand in hand, and a fence closed right after they came in for reasons unknown.
The subversion of the title (and the “it was bound to happen eventually”, of sapphic risky decisions) is the cherry on top of a _really_ delicious sundae.
Reasons unknown, but highly guessable, given the environment. I’m willing to bet the fence is there to keep the protesters caged in and agitate them so they’re more likely to act up, like in real life.
NO PR(oresting?)
BY CI(ty?)
COUN(cil?)
ORD(inance?)
… Yeah, ok, they’re guessable alright. Thank you! :33
I meant it more like, we don’t know how it’s gonna develop (including when shit’s gonna hit the fan.) I’m seated, though ^^ It’s gonna be a tricky storyline to navigate, what with the Very Real Life parallels (that keep and keep going, gdi) — but I wholly trust Willis as a storyteller.
Do we have a volume title? I think we have a volume title
The advice being said here is good just y’know, if anyone’s in the US right now…
Heck, this is probably more of a nod to the Gaza college encampments and it was good advice THEN, too…
Things have been bad and just continue to shit, huh?
Things have been bad for quite a while, yes. Honestly, I don’t think it’s ever stopped getting worse since at least 9/11, and probably before that. People like to pretend 2016 was some sort of anomaly that marked the start of the Current Shit, but it was consistently horrid for a long time beforehand.
Even since the Kent State murders in 1970.
I was going to say Nixon getting off with nothing more than a resignation but then I checked the dates and you make a good point.
I just want to point out the fact that Joyce has, at this point, been drugged and nearly raped, smashed the girl’s face open with glass, rode with Sal to rescue her best friend from being kidnapped by an armed gunman, was kidnapped, hogtied in a basement, where it was apparent that endgame was their death, was the one chosen by her group of abductees as the one most rage-filled and therefore the most dangerous, then got kidnapped again and helped toss a kid to be caught in midair by a motorcycle.
But no, they’re going to a peaceful protest on campus and THIS is what is truly terrifying.
I’m not sure if they’re so PTSD’d that something which is truly mildly subversive is in actuality akin to walking in a warzone, or if in this universe, college protests are extremely unusual and often put down with lethal force and extreme prejudice.
Its admittedly been a while since I was in college, but there’d be protests half the weekend about one thing or another.
I would encourage you to look into the way anti-police/anti-war/anti-genocide protests in the States have been responded to by police in recent years in the universe we live in.
I’m not denying at all that there’s a small percentage of peaceful protests that do result in a some level of police retaliation and arrests, or of violence in general.
What I stand by – and I 100% do – is that it is safer to enter a peaceful demonstration, with a buddy, long enough to find your sister, deliver a message, and leave – something that should take ten to fifteen minutes tops – than for two short underage college girls to go alone to a bar, get smashed drunk, and stagger through the streets of their town completely inebriated until they get back on campus. And they willingly chose to do the former without much thought to the consequences.
I’m not sure about the timeline depending on the size and vibe of the protest, but I do agree with your overall idea. What’s interesting is that they’ve been conditioned to think of the protest option as scary and the bar option as normal– which I think is the case for a lot of people their age. Many people do things that can be very scary or risky all the time, but they don’t think of them that way because the things are “normal.”
Both things they should be able to do without real danger, but unfortunately it’s a risk to some degree in each.
From an outside perspective, it makes sense to think that the chances of them encountering danger during this task are low, even if they don’t feel that way. Then you take another step in perspective to consider that this is a comic and we expect some sort of even to happen, and I can see where readers might be worried about something happening to them.
They’re obviously arriving at a dramatic moment, considering the fence being put up, but yeah, there’s definitely conditioning to think of protesting as scary (and we see it not just with them, but with a lot of commenters).
I think everything I would say is the summary that one of the Palestinian protestors only just now got released and the President still wants him in jail.
Yeah, and that’s absolutely indefensible, but it’s still one out of how many?
That’s not the common experience. Not the usual outcome of going to a protest.
The level of danger also varies by protest and the likelihood of something happening while there also varies with how long someone is there. Like, definitely getting some clues that Dorothy and Joyce just have the worst timing, but presumably there have been plenty of other fifteen minute windows where they would have been fine.
It definitely does. Most protest rally kind of things are almost completely safe – like the No Kings last weekend. Encampments like this are higher risk, since they’re likely eventually going to be cleared out. Even then, there’s usually the opportunity to leave before the cops decide to go in with force.
If you’re going to night protests where there’s already been violence on previous days? Be ready for street fighting.
They’re being fenced in.
For real, though. If someone tries to genuinely hurt Joyce or Dorothy, Joyce is just gonna go all Kaio-ken on their ass and probably Amazi-Girl will show up to punch several identical white guys. It’ll be a fun fight scene, but I’ll change my name to Punished Taffy for a month if Joyce or Dorothy gets any injury more severe than a mild black eye.
this is a peaceful protest in the states. things are crazy here and have been for a long time
Police in the US often don’t treat protesters very well, especially when those protesters are protesting against genocide, war, or previous bad actions of the police.
Or current bad actions by the police.
This is all true, but at the same time, the danger is often wildly overstated. The vast majority of protesters walk away completely unharmed. Shit does happen. The police do get violent and there’s no excuse for that, but still overwhelmingly it’s still safe to protest. The media focuses on the violence of course, so that sets the impression.
Go protest. You’re not actually taking your life in your hands.
I would like to point out that I, personally, am a person within the United States who has been a part of more than one protest, and yet somehow I am both alive, without an arrest record, and in possession of most of my teeth.
For everyone saying, “OK, but you’re CLEARLY not familiar with how protests go in Amurica, they have guns and evil police,” congrats, you’re engaging in stereotype.
Yeah because nothing bad having happen to you personally is representative of everyone’s experience
It’s not their fault you’re too stupid to understand the difference between a recounted personal experience and a sweeping statement of all humans.
You are fucking exhausting today.
You don’t have any room to complain about me.
Protests can go bad. No one’s denying that. Police violence does happen. Protestor violence happens too, though more rarely. People get arrested unjustly. These things happen. They shouldn’t. It’s indefensible.
But it’s also not the common experience. Vast majority of protestors don’t go through any of that.
Why are we so dedicated to pushing the idea that protesting is incredibly dangerous? Who does that serve?
Nobody had that said anything about protesting been “Incredibly dangerous” here just the regular amount of dangerous you seem to agree to.
I think thejeff is pointing to the strip at this point. Narratives about the dangers of protesting, particularly those centered on main characters, create the impression that such dangers are ‘typical’ of protests in general. This, in turn, creates reluctance to actually engage in protests, thereby diminishing their effectiveness.
Yeah, I don’t really get the scaremongering. Even simple statements like “I don’t think they’re in much danger” is just being invariably met with “But real protests can be dangerous”, like that’s supposed to fix our flawed naivete and make us scared for Joyce and Dorothy.
I’m arguing that it’s unreasonable to, when showing up to a protest for a planned fifteen minute jaunt, be loudly terrified that you might be killed, because the chances of that happening are incredibly miniscule.
25 people were killed in the US in 2020 while protesting. There were over 10,600 protests across the US that year. Statistics show that over 95% were completely peaceful, and that there was no property damage or physical injury, either on police or protestor side, for 98% of them.
Protest sizes ranged from a few hundred to a few thousand, so let’s be generous here and say that there was, on average, 300 attendees for each protest. That would mean that your chance of being killed attending a protest in 2020 would be 1 in 127,200.
In comparison, statistics by the National Safety Council also show that your chance of being in a car accident is roughly 1 in 366 for every 1,000 miles you drive. If you crunch the numbers – and I did – that means that if you drove five miles to get to the protest, you were in more danger driving to the protest than participating in it.
But no, I’m the one using anecdotes to try to push a narrative, rather than demonstrate that Joyce and Dorothy are perhaps being a tad melodramatic when they exclaim loudly that they sure hope they’ll keep being alive.
I’m inclined to take the word of someone who’s actually been at a protest and didn’t die, over the incessant pants-wetting of people who are too afraid to even consider the odds of returning alive might be higher than 0%.
And you know what that is not an stereotype that is an accurate statement about america. It got a massive gun and police violence problem, it’s not up for debate.
I think you don’t know what the word ‘stereotype’ means.
As you stand here making a loud, unshakable statement about a different group of people, which you have gathered from a lot of what has been said about those people, and refuse to listen to reasoned arguments that claim that yes, while SOME are like this, you cannot assume that ALL are like this, or even MOST are like this. You instead say, no, I am not debating or discussing this, those people have a massive problem, it is exactly what I say it is.
Okay, and did all of them involve people coming from outside the school, like Joss has, news coverage, which is how Hank knows about this, and someone cordoning off the area, like we’re seeing in this strip? Or does that suggest something bigger and potentially more likely to involve polive violence than protests that happen “half the weekend about one thing or another”?
*police violence, not polive.
So, I just did a little digging, and looked up what was happening with protests at UIB specifically during the time these strips would’ve been written. A pro-protest site I found did not talk about actual serious injuries or deaths; it did, however, talk about temporary arrests (charges were ultimately not filed, due to the prosecutors’ concerns that the arrests themselves were unconstitutional) and the University coming up with very targeted policies about ‘temporary structures’ meant to disperse the protestors, and about students being charged with violations of UIB policy–which could lead to suspension from campus.
Interestingly, the non-lethal consequences I mention above are actually, by virtue of being non-lethal, absolutely something that could happen to one or both of the girls, with long-lasting ramifications (especially for Dotty–an arrest for being a protestor would absolutely be the final nail in the coffin to her political ambitions).
theyre HOLDING HANDSSSSSS
do u think they held hands the whole walk over, i think they did, oh they’re so girlfriends <3
They definitely did. I wonder how long they managed to separate their hands while they were getting dressed. I imagine seconds at most, just long enough to slip a sleeve past.
Maybe they don’t want to get separated at a protest. Boring answer.
Super boring, since they’re holding hands well before they actually enter the protest crowd.
guess this won’t,at worst, serve as a humanizing anecdote
borrowed the hat, nice
Innumerous? That’s a new one on me. Must be another linguistic difference I was not aware of, not having met it before!
There are a lot of differences between various English dialects, yes. Some might say an uncountable number of them.
aw the resolution got reverted. here i was thinking that it was uploaded in hd specifically so we could see dotty and joyce holding hands LOL
Wayback Machine gotcha back.
This feels like a finale of a sort is coming.
I’m not sure what you mean?
Well, they’re calling back the punchline, for one.
Protesters could jump in the waterway if kettled?
i wonder when this was put onto the buffer, and also in the real world if IU’s given in to one of the Elise Stefaniks of the GOP.
The argument about not having your phone and disguising your identity is good to avoid the police arresting you or harrassing you. Other people think that you actually have to be willing to be arrested to make the protests work. Sadly, very few people want to be a martyr nor should anyone have to be.
Being arrested is a valid protest tactic, but it’s far from the only or most effective one.
I generally support people who choose themselves to be in danger in order to make their voices heard.
Those who demand others put themselves in danger for the same purpose, generally get the side-eye from me.
It’s not like we have evidence that the local police are corrupt and tied to the mob. Willing to kill to protect themselves from discovery. They wouldn’t hurt someone in a public place like a park or a hospital. And get totally away with it.
Honestly I’m really proud of both of them. Something like this would have been too politically dangerous for Dorothy, once. And unthinkable for Joyce, once.
BE QUEER; DO PROTESTS.
A callback!
We do love a callback.
Oh my Cheese I love the callback!
Well, silver lining, Mary’s now in a cage too.
…. I mean, she has to be, right? It’s not like the power structures at hand would treat the protest and counter-protest with anything other than total, even-handed equality, right? Right?
Just wanted to check in, in case anyone is having a hard time today.
Remember that peer support is always available.
For example
https://translifeline.org/
877-565-8860
“I feel naked without my phone.”
“Me, too.”
…
…
*handholding intensifies*
That “portion alive” bit would make a great title for the next book.
Especially if it includes some Mike flashback or other bonus material
So what are the odds that Jocelyn gets dumped into a van by the police and triggers Dorothy?
Be gay, do crime that topple oppressive power structures
Is it gay to do callbacks with your best friend
Only if you do them right.